"Stool ball: an early bat and ball game" by Lady Wenyeva atte grene.
This article was submitted to me by the author for inclusion in this set of files, called Stefan's Florilegium.
These files are available on the Internet at: http://www.florilegium.org
Copyright to the contents of this file remains with the author or translator.
While the author will likely give permission for this work to be reprinted in SCA type publications, please check with the author first or check for any permissions granted at the end of this file.
Mark S. Harris...AKA:..Stefan li Rous
stefan at florilegium.org
You can find more good articles by this author on her webpage at: http://slumberland.org/sca/
Stool ball: an early bat and ball game
by Lady Wenyeva atte grene
The game we know as baseball may be relatively modern, but it has medieval roots. Many bat-and-ball games were played throughout the Middle Ages at religious festivals and events. One game, stool ball (sometimes possibly stow ball, or stob ball, or stump ball) dates back at least to the 14th century, and many historians believe that it is the common ancestor of both baseball and cricket. It was also the first bat-and-ball-type game known to have been played in North America (at Plymouth in 1621 at Christmastime, no less, much to the chagrin of Governor Bradford). In this game, the pitcher tries to hit a stool or stump with the ball, while the batter tries to defend the target using bare hands or a bat.
Stool ball was known for being played by both women and men together, and there are indications that it was a sort of springtime ritual, played at Eastertime. Some of the poetic mentions of the game imply an undertone of sexuality; "playing at stool ball" was used at least once as an euphemism.
In many stool ball games, tansy-cakes were the traditional winners' prize. Tansy-cakes were a traditional Eastertime food (see here, and a recipe here), so this is another connection of stool ball to Easter celebrations.
Unfortunately, no one knows what the rules of the period versions of stool ball were. As a folk game, it was likely to have varying rules at various times and places. From post-period references to the game, we know that in some versions of the game, there was no bat, and hands were used instead. Other versions had no baserunning, just a single stool or stump base that the batter was expected to defend.. But bats and running the bases were included in some versions, too.
This is a "historically plausible" version of the game. Since we don't know much about how the medieval game was played, I tried to extrapolate from what little we do know about stool ball and related historic bat and ball games, as well as making the game simple, friendly, and safe for players of all ages and abilities. The result is a game that bears some resemblance to both cricket and baseball, though it is much simpler than either, and is quite believable as a medieval game -- and it's a lot of fun!
The field dimensions aren't strict. This is just a suggested size. The game can be played in a smaller area or even indoors, though it's harder to score runs on a smaller field.
A stool, chair, or stump is placed at Home, and another one (or a similar marker) as the Base. Mark the Batter's Line with something visible, like a stick or a strip of fabric, etc. The pitcher stands near the Base and throws the ball underhand toward Home, trying to hit the Home stool with the pitch. The batter stands at the Batter's Line and tries to prevent the pitcher's throw from hitting the Home stool, by hitting the ball away with the bat. If the batter hits the ball, he can run around the Base and back Home, and if he does this before the fielders can hit the Home stool with the ball, he scores a run. Team with the most runs wins!
Rules (Sort of)
1. Swing as much as you want! There are no ŇstrikesÓ or ŇballsÓ. The batter stays at bat until a hit is made or the pitcher hits the Home with the ball.
2. Any contact is a hit. There are no ŇfoulsÓ or Ňfoul tipsÓ. RUN!
3. On hitting the ball, the batter must run counterclockwise around the outside of the Base. The batter may not stop on the Base – once you start running, you have to run around the Base and all the way back home. You must touch the Home stool when you get there, but you donŐt have to touch the Base.
4. Batter is out when:
a. The pitcher hits Home with the ball while the batter is at bat
b. Any fielder catches the hit ball in the air, without a bounce
c. Any fielder hits Home with the ball while the batter is running to Base and back to Home. ButÉ
5. Fielders must be on the Base side of the BatterŐs Line when throwing the ball to Home. So if the batter hits the ball behind Home (what in baseball would be a foul), the batter runs, and the fielders can go get the ballÉ but they canŐt throw it at Home and put the batter out until they get back on the other side of the batterŐs line.
6. Every player on the team gets one at-bat per inning. Each team gets the same number of innings at bat, but other than that the game can go on until the teams mutually agree to quit.
7. All players must have fun! J
Equipment is simple. You need a very soft ball. (Not a softball or a baseball!) A soft ball can be walloped pretty hard, but no gloves or helmets are necessary for safe play. You can use a medieval pattern that will provide a ball of just about the perfect softness, though if you don't have time to make a ball, you will probably be able to find a ball at a toy store that will work. A Nerf ball might work.
The ball pictured on the right was made from a pattern that was used for many leather balls throughout medieval Europe. The pattern is pictured on the left (not to scale). The three pieces were cut from soft leather. They were sewn together inside-out until only a slit remained. Then the ball was turned rightside-out and stuffed with scraps of woven wool fabric until it seemed to be the right amount, and has become ball-shaped instead of cylindrical. The last slit was then stitched up. Then I topstitched over the entire ball for durability.
Amazingly, this ball has some bounce to it, and it's easy to catch bare-handed because it has some give. With the topstitching, it has held up through several games so far, and I haven't had to resort to the spare toy store balls I brought in case of emergency.
The bat can be anything that seems to work for you. A baseball bat is probably overkill (as well as obtrusively modern), but in a pinch, it will work. I decided to make something that sort of resembled a cricket bat, or a bread paddle, or a butter paddle. The modern-day stool ball players in Sussex use something that looks like a table tennis paddle with a long handle. Early stool ball players just hit the ball with their hands, so you can do that too!
My stool ball bat, as seen in the photo below, is about 24 inches long, cut from a poplar board. I finished it with wood stain and painted my badge on it. The handle is wrapped with a strip of leather. The bat is fairly lightweight, so players of all ages have had no trouble with it.
You will also need a stool to serve as Home (a short three-legged stool, like a milking stool, works really well, but a tree stump works too. In a pinch we use camping chairs, but their larger size tends to make it easier to hit the stool with the ball, and so the game is more low-scoring), and something to mark the base (another stool, or a post, etc.). Something to mark the batter's line, such as a piece of string, is good to have as well.
That is all the equipment necessary!
Alternative ways to play
Every village probably had its own way to play, just as many households today have their own "house rules" for Monopoly. So if you want to change the game, go right ahead! Here are some ideas, marked with a * if they are period or likely-period variations:
1. Use your bare hands to hit the ball instead of the bat. *
2. Add the "soak 'em" rule: Runners can be put out by hitting them with the ball (don't do this unless your ball is very soft!). *
3. Add the retaliation rule: When teams change sides, if the team that has just gone "out" can run onto the field, pick up the ball, and hit one of the other team's members before they leave the field, the "out" team gets to bat again! This can be really rowdy. It's an authentic rule from several early bat and ball games, including early baseball. *
4. Allow runners to stop at the base instead of having to run around it without stopping. Also, one might add multiple bases. *
5. Require that fielders only catch the ball in their clothing: their skirts or hats, for example.
Sources for further information
á Baseball Before We Knew It: A Search For The Roots Of The Game, David Block. University of Nebraska Press, 2005.
á Ball, Bat and Bishop: The Origin of Ball Games, Robert W. Henderson. University of Illinois Press, 2001.
Balls!, Aelflaed of the Weald. http://aelflaed.homemail.com.au/doco/balls.html
Copyright 2007 by Wendi Dunlap, Seattle, WA. <wd-sca at slumberland.org>. Permission is granted for republication in SCA-related publications, provided the author is credited. Please include her name, e-mail, and website link in any republication. Addresses change, but a reasonable attempt should be made to ensure that the author is notified of the publication and if possible receives a copy.
If this article is reprinted in a publication, I would appreciate a notice in the publication that you found this article in the Florilegium. I would also appreciate an email to myself, so that I can track which articles are being reprinted. Thanks. -Stefan.