p-backpacks-msg - 9/14/98 Period backpacks, bags and carrying baskets. NOTE: See also these files: travel-msg, rope-msg, carts-msg, basketweaving-msg. ************************************************************************ NOTICE - This file is a collection of various messages having a common theme that I have collected from my reading of the various computer networks. Some messages date back to 1989, some may be as recent as yesterday. This file is part of a collection of files called Stefan's Florilegium. These files are available on the Internet at: http://www.florilegium.org I have done a limited amount of editing. Messages having to do with separate topics were sometimes split into different files and sometimes extraneous information was removed. For instance, the message IDs were removed to save space and remove clutter. The comments made in these messages are not necessarily my viewpoints. I make no claims as to the accuracy of the information given by the individual authors. Please respect the time and efforts of those who have written these messages. The copyright status of these messages is unclear at this time. If information is published from these messages, please give credit to the originator(s). Thank you, Mark S. Harris AKA: THLord Stefan li Rous Stefan at florilegium.org ************************************************************************ From: cat at fgssu1.sinet.slb.COM (CoreDumps`R'Us) Date: 4 Dec 91 02:19:43 GMT Organization: The Internet Yaakov asks if leather backpacks were period. Well, I have some opinions, and I have some facts. First, the facts: I asked myself a similiar question a few years ago, and went looking at period illustrations for the types of bags that people used to carry their stuff in. I looked at illustrations of over a hundred manuscripts, everything I could lay my hands on. I have that list at home, but the thought of typing up onto the rialto makes my skin scrawl. Trust me, I did this, ok? In all of the manuscripts I looked at (mostly english and burgundian, with some "german" thrown in wherever I could find them, mostly all 14th and 15th century, but more on that in a bit), I found nothing that I would discribe as a period backpack. This surprised me. Let me tell you why: I know of a period backback, but I'll get to that in a minute. Knowing that such a thing existed, I went looking for it in manuscripts of the appropriate time frame (ie 14th and 15th centuries). The pack I know of is german, which is why I wanted more german illustra-` tions than I found). Not even the later illustrations (Durer and Altdorfer and Cranach woodcuts) turns up the pack I was looking for. Now there are things that sort of serve the purpose. There's a bag that's thrown over the shoulder, and sort of looks like a cross between a large lady's shoulder purse (the really BIG ones from the sixties, though you still see some still) and a rolled up blanket. Master Allan o'Duhdd..., oh however you spell his name, you know... Master Allan "O'DooDah", former Triton Herald of Atlantia, he has one and has the pattern for how he made it. There's another sort of "bag" which is also along the "rolled blanket" style (and in fact may be the same as the above, except carried differ- ently), but you generally see it suspended from the strap (knotted) about the forehead with the load hanging down the back. You also see it with both ends slung up over the shoulders, UNKNOTTED, each loose end grabbed in a hand, with the load again on the back. As far as a pack that looks like one of the modern day packs that people us for bookbags these day: never saw one. Now the pack which I know is real: it's actually Tirollean, 15th century, and the pattern has carried down to the 20th century, almost unchanged (*GASP*). It's the "external frame" backpack. It was invented IN PERIOD. (Awesome, isn't it?) The one I know exists is in the Tirolischer Volkskunst Museum in Innsbruck. I saw it there, along with all sorts of other nifty stuff (medieval tirolean folk art is some of the niftiest stuff going, IMHO). I have been kicking myself for years for not having taken pictures when I was there. If you ever get to Inns- bruck, go to this museum!!! It will tweak your view of medieval art, if nothing else. The people who lived isolated in those mountain valleys in the Alps developed some really left-field cultural variations, especially in local custom and art. So now that I've rambled on about my few facts, let me bless you all with my opinions... (here soapbox, here boy.... heeeere soapboooooooox!!!!... oh, there you are, playing with the kitten again I see...so nice of you to come home from minnesota, but the way...what happened? it start snowing up there yet? have you come to spend the winter in sunny California, hm???) While external frame backpacks and big shoulder bags are real in period, I really don't think the modern teardrop-shaped backpack existed in the medieval or renaissance periods. Even then, the shoulder bag things look like they're made of cloth (look at the examples in the Tres Riches Heures de Jean, Duc de Berry and in the paintings by Bruegal the elder). The external frame backpack was a mountain developement (you need your hands free in the high passes), and was made of wood, with rawhide or leather ties (I couldn't get close enough to tell - the thing was an exhibit, dis- played on a dummy many feet away - this was one of those museums which hasn't felt compelled to put it's stuff behind glass yet, but set up it's artifacts in rooms, with roped walkways going through the middle, from room to room...or at least that was the case when I was there last). Items you wanted to carry were wrapped up and tied onto the frame directly. So I think the "period backpack" doesn't exist. One of these days, I'm going to bother to write up all this strange stuff I research...there's too much crammed in my head, and not enough of it on paper... Maybe I should get a ghost writer... Twcs, imfamous welshified Tirolean person From: cctimar at athena.cas.vanderbilt.edu (Charles) Date: 4 Dec 91 07:42:05 GMT Organization: Vanderbilt University student of numerology Therasia von Tux writeth: > Yaakov asks if leather backpacks were period. Well, I have some > opinions, and I have some facts. Another lead: Late period (1590's) Shakespeare, As You Like It, in Jacques soliloquy on "The Seven Ages of Man" mentions, "the schoolboy, his satchel on his back." Shakespeare was paraphrasing earlier authors describing how to play various standard roles, so there is probably mention of such things in sixteenth century English, French, and Italian texts on drama. Incidentally, the 3000 yr old corpse discovered in the Alps last year - wasn't he wearing a leather backpack of some sort? -- -- Charles, student, in Glaedenfeld, Meridies From: bnostrand at lynx.northeastern.EDU Date: 4 Dec 91 14:52:17 GMT Organization: The Internet A while back when Lord Yaakov was characterizing different participants in this forum he left me out. Thus, I prompted him to characterize me as well and he said "and Solveig chimes in with the Japanese version of things." Forgive me M'Lord if I have misquoted you. So now for backpacks in Japan. Japanese use an external frame backpack which I believe is similar to the Austrian one describe here recently. (I have not actually seen the Austrian backpack.) The Japanese version (which is still in use) consists of a frame of sawn wooden sticks with a bottem shelf which is held together by a lattice of knotted cords. I believe that I have seen these in both period illustrations and in museums as well as in motion pictures and in actual use in the mountains. I believe that there is another type of pack (I have or at least had a minature of this one) which is essentially a wicker work affair or rather like an open basket with straps. Leather was a rather scarce commodity in Japan and I suspect in Europe as well. I think that this accounts for the relative absence of leather backpacks. I believe that I have also seen illustrations of jewish pedlars carrying large bags which appear to have been made from canvas. Another method of transporting things is to suspend them from a pole ballanced from the shoulders. Regardless. The Japanse were very aware of the efficiency of carrying things on the shoulders and even have a word which basically means "to shoulder a load." Solveig Throndardottir From: habura at vccsouth25.its.rpi.edu (Andrea Marie Habura) Date: 4 Dec 91 16:02:24 GMT Organization: Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy NY Interestingly, the big shoulder bag survived until well out of period; I used one when I was in a fife-and-drum corps. It was called a "haversack" in the 18th century. They are quite handy, as I recall. Alison MacDermot Date: Wed, 19 Aug 1998 9:59:08 -0500 From: "I. Marc Carlson" Subject: re: travel gear Newsgroups: rec.org.sca > > What sort of gear would a foot soldier use to transport his perssonal > gear from place to place in the 13th and 14th centuries? I was thinking > that it would be very convenient if I made an all -leather, period (or > period-like) back pack to carry stuff about an event site during the > day. I've seen references to something called a 'scrip', but the > descriptions were pretty vague, and I took them to be something akin to > a large leather bag with a strap worn across the body, over the opposite > shoulder. First let me point out that nomenclature is not a constant in all places and all times, and a term that might refer to one thing in one place may be used elsewhere in a totally different (but still related) fashion. A "scrip" (derived probaly from the Old French "escreppe" - wallet, bag, purse for alms) refers to "a small bag, wallet or satchel, especially one carried by a pilgrim, shepherd, or a beggar" (OED2d). I have seen it used to refer to everything from a "belf pouch" to a "Pilgrim's Purse", so it would appear that your definition was correct. There is also a term that I think is sometimes spelled "Gipser" usually meaning a purse, pouch or wallet that hangs from a belt or girdle, but I have also seen used to refer to an over the shoulder bag (it has been suggested that the term is derived from the old French for "Game Bag", but this is not proven). There is a way of carrying your goods wrapped up and tied around the waist, carried in a manner similar to those babyslings you sometimes see today. I believe there is a picture of a man in the Luttrell Psalter carrying a woven basket in the manner of a backpack, although although the main strap crosses in front of him from shoulder to shoulder, sort of like a yoke. Unfortunately, I can't find it this morning, so you may want to take that with some salt. In general, however, I believe it is fairly safe to say that there is not much in the way of documentation or historical examples of medieval backpacks. Marc/Diarmaid lib_imc at centum.utulsa.edu From: Tanya Guptill Organization: Sysco Food Services Newsgroups: rec.org.sca Subject: Re: travel gear Date: Fri, 21 Aug 1998 17:28:57 GMT There is a wonderful article about how to construct an alms satchel at http://www.iinet.net.au/~expo/sven/psatchel.html , by Stephen Wyley. I don't know if it would be large enough to house the gear you carry, but it might be a good start. Mira From: hrjones at uclink.berkeley.edu (Heather Rose Jones) Newsgroups: rec.org.sca Subject: Re: travel gear Date: 21 Aug 1998 18:23:22 GMT Organization: University of California, Berkeley David Serhienko (tigycho at earthlink.net) wrote: : Does anyone have references, patterns, or images on backpacks or scrips : or anything else of that sort which might fit the bill? In medieval and renaissance art from at least England and France (quite likely other areas, but those are the ones I know) you frequently see people using basketry "backpacks" to transport agricultural products (e.g., grapes) or construction materials and byproducts (e.g., dirt). The general form seems to have been a truncated cone shape with shoulder straps added. (I've even seen similar items available for sale in upscale basketry stores.) However note that these are being used for "industrial" transport in very specific contexts (e.g., during harvest) and it is not clear that similar items would have been used for transporting personal posessions and the like by travellers. Tangwystyl verch Morgant Glasvryn From: dpeters at panix.com (D. Peters) Newsgroups: rec.org.sca Subject: Re: travel gear Date: 23 Aug 1998 17:44:13 -0400 Heather Rose Jones wrote: >David Serhienko (tigycho at earthlink.net) wrote: >: Does anyone have references, patterns, or images on backpacks or scrips >: or anything else of that sort which might fit the bill? > >In medieval and renaissance art from at least England and France (quite >likely other areas, but those are the ones I know) you frequently see >people using basketry "backpacks" to transport agricultural products >(e.g., grapes) or construction materials and byproducts (e.g., dirt). The >general form seems to have been a truncated cone shape with shoulder >straps added. (I've even seen similar items available for sale in upscale >basketry stores.) However note that these are being used for "industrial" >transport in very specific contexts (e.g., during harvest) and it is not >clear that similar items would have been used for transporting personal >posessions and the like by travellers. I happen to have a book about Hieronymous Bosch at hand; two paintings ("The Road of Life," the exterior panels of the "Haywain" triptych; and "The Wayfarer") show a down-at-his heels peasant or pilgrim carrying his goods in a wooden-lidded, woven hamper with a strap running across his chest from shoulder to shoulder. Not too dissimilar to the pack baskets one sees at Pennsic. Although these pictures are realistically rendered, without any of Bosch's characteristic biomorphic wonders, artistic evidence may need to be taken with a grain of salt. Usual disclaimers apply. D.Peters Date: Mon, 24 Aug 1998 11:36:24 -0500 From: "I. Marc Carlson" Subject: re: Backpacks Newsgroups: rec.org.sca On 24 Aug 1998, Bill Schongar wrote: > What did the Romans use to carry gear? I have some vague (but > not substantiated in any way) recollection that they had some > kind of individual carrying arrangements... > Or maybe I'm just imagining a kind of 'Packs' Imperium.. ; ) Um, right :) I don't recall if they used "packs", although I think a lot of the Legions' material good were carried from poles, not unlike bindlestiffs, when they were just moving from place to place. Of course, even if the Romans *did* use them, that also doesn't mean that they used them in the Middle Ages. Only finding examples from the Middle Ages would tell us that they they were used in the Middle Ages (from the point and time they were found). Marc/Diarmaid Date: Tue, 25 Aug 1998 9:23:33 -0500 From: "I. Marc Carlson" Subject: Backpacks and Travel Gear Newsgroups: rec.org.sca From: Kathryn M Gomm To: LIB_IMC at centum.utulsa.edu Marc/Diarmaid - This is in response to your posting on the Rialto regarding travel gear. Unfortunately, I an unable to directly respond using that forum, so feel free to forward this if you wish. You mention "I believe it is fairly safe to say that there is not much in the way of documentation or historical examples of medieval backpacks." To this, I would say, perhaps. As a basketweaver, I am always on the lookout for depictions in manuscripts and paintings of baskets. As you may well know, certain textiles do not survive to the present, and baskets are one of them. There are few extant baskets from SCA period, and I have seen a few of them. However, I digress. Backpacks. The following is a list of manuscripts/paintings which have figures wearing backpacks. Granted, most of them are for agricultural uses, but they are nonetheless backpacks. I would also point out that these depictions tend to be wickerwork baskets, and not the splint ones we see for sale at Pennsic. From "A Medieval Book of Seasons" by Collis and Davis p12 Pierpont Morgan Library, NY. MS 399, Bruges, about 1520 p28 Musee Conde, Chantilly. P. De Crecens, "Le Rustican" about 1460 p105 British Library, London. Add. MS 38126 f9 Hours of the Virgin illuminated by various artists, Flemish, about 1500 From "Medieval Woman Calendar 1996" September "The Wine Harvest" wool & silk tapestry, French, early 16th century. Musee Nationale de Moyen Age, Paris From "Hieronymus Bosch" Bosing p62 "The Wayfarer" El Escorial, Monasterio de San Lorenzo pp64-65 "The Wayfarer" Rotterdam, Museum Boymans-van Beuningen From "The Complete Woodcuts of Albrecht Durer" Kurth plate118 "Repose on the Flight into Egypt" B.90. H1770. R77, 1504 or 1505 So you see, there are several examples. You may point out that these are all later-period depictions, but I would have to counter that baskets are a rare sight in most manuscripts prior to the 15th century in general. I hope this has been of interest to you. If you have further questions, or examples I have not cited, please share any information you may have. Thank you. Dore' van der Zee (Kathryn Gomm) Date: Thu, 27 Aug 1998 15:41:24 -0500 From: "I. Marc Carlson" Subject: re: Travel Gear Newsgroups: rec.org.sca > >Backpacks. The following is a list of manuscripts/paintings which have >figures wearing backpacks. Granted, most of them are for agricultural >uses, but they are nonetheless backpacks. I would also point out that >these depictions tend to be wickerwork baskets, and not the splint ones we >see for sale at Pennsic. >From "A Medieval Book of Seasons" by Collis and Davis >p12 Pierpont Morgan Library, NY. MS 399, Bruges, about 1520 >p28 Musee Conde, Chantilly. P. De Crecens, "Le Rustican" about 1460 >p105 British Library, London. Add. MS 38126 f9 Hours of the Virgin >illuminated by various artists, Flemish, about 1500 >From "Medieval Woman Calendar 1996" >September "The Wine Harvest" wool & silk tapestry, French, early 16th >century. Musee Nationale de Moyen Age, Paris I haven't been able to find copies of these yes, so I can't comment on them. >From "Hieronymus Bosch" Bosing >p62 "The Wayfarer" El Escorial, Monasterio de San Lorenzo >pp64-65 "The Wayfarer" Rotterdam, Museum Boymans-van Beuningen Could you give me an idea where in the picture this is? I can see the lady carrying hay on her back, the baby carried in the hood. I'm sure I'm just missing it. >From "The Complete Woodcuts of Albrecht Durer" Kurth >plate118 "Repose on the Flight into Egypt" B.90. H1770. R77, 1504 or 1505 That's plate 188 :) And yes, there is the wearing basket that the angels are sticking wood wood chips into. And it does have what look to be shoulder straps. >So you see, there are several examples. You may point out that these are >all later-period depictions, but I would have to counter that baskets are >a rare sight in most manuscripts prior to the 15th century in general. I'm not going to fuss too badly, at this moment :) What interests me is that the basket has two arm straps, such as we'd see today, and not a shoulder to shoulder chest strap. >I hope this has been of interest to you. If you have further questions, or >examples I have not cited, please share any information you may have. Oh, I'm sure I'll come up with something eventually. With regards to Bill Schongar, the gentleman who offered the piece from the Horizon Book of the Middle Ages -- nice picture, thank you. It's a clear enough statue to see how most of the strapping seems to work. It misses showing where the straps go underneath, but I think I can guess. Essentially, it's a man carrying a box (which would be to scale about 18"x18-20"x 6-10") on his back. The box is held in place by two (and perhaps three) straps. The long strap appears to be either a single strap, looping over the top and sides of the box, crossing underneath, then coming up over the arms and across the chest (or else it is one loop, wrapped around the box and holding all the other straps in place, and a second loop coming up from the bottom of the box over his shoulders and around his chest). The other strap crosses the back of the box, over the shoulders, under the arms, and vanishing God only knows where (I suspect across his back, under the box). Based on the strapping pattern, you'd set the straps in place, then the one that goes around the box to hold them in place. You'd pull the chest strap over your head (which means that you'd likely need a table to do this, or help), and when it was settled, you'd stick your arms through the arms straps, and they'd hold the chest band secure. OTOH, the statue is lacking a lot of other details that could make things easier, like buckles :) So. People were carrying things on their backs. It doesn't seem to have been very common, and still doesn't look like what we think of as a back pack, and especially not the framed alpine style worn by the Iceman. Marc/Diarmaid Date: Fri, 28 Aug 1998 11:46:09 -0500 From: "I. Marc Carlson" Subject: re: Travel Gear Newsgroups: rec.org.sca I'm assuming that Kathryn wants to continue this publically, but since she can not currently post to the Rialto, I am forwarding her response before replying myself. M/D ==================== Date: Fri, 28 Aug 1998 10:56:27 -0500 (CDT) From: Kathryn M Gomm To: "I. Marc Carlson" Subject: re: Travel Gear Marc/Diarmaid: Thank you for your response. I guess I had misunderstood the original post looking for backpacks and had only responded to that portion of the question. I wish to continue this conversation, and will point out the various methods of straps used in the paintings and illustrations I cite. me>From "A Medieval Book of Seasons" by Collis and Davis me>p12 Pierpont Morgan Library, NY. MS 399, Bruges, about 1520 me>p28 Musee Conde, Chantilly. P. De Crecens, "Le Rustican" about 1460 me>p105 British Library, London. Add. MS 38126 f9 Hours of the Virgin me>illuminated by various artists, Flemish, about 1500 me>From "Medieval Woman Calendar 1996" me>September "The Wine Harvest" wool & silk tapestry, French, early 16th me>century. Musee Nationale de Moyen Age, Paris you>I haven't been able to find copies of these yes, so I can't comment you>on them. In "A Medieval Book of Seasons" the illustrations on pages 12 and 28 are unclear for the strap arrangement. On page 105, the backpack appears to have arm straps (like today's backpacks). The picture in the "Medieval Woman Calendar 1996, September" the straps go across the front of the man's body. me>From "Hieronymus Bosch" Bosing me>p62 "The Wayfarer" El Escorial, Monasterio de San Lorenzo me>pp64-65 "The Wayfarer" Rotterdam, Museum Boymans-van Beuningen you>Could you give me an idea where in the picture this is? I can see the you>lady carrying hay on her back, the baby carried in the hood. I'm sure you>I'm just missing it. I'm not sure we are talking about the same pictures. The complete book title is "Hieronymus Bosch, c1450 - 1516, Between Heaven and Hell" by Walter Bosing, printed by Benedikt Taschen, 1987. They both clearly have a man in the center of the painting, who is wearing a backpack. The straps go across the front of his chest. I have yet to see the picture in the Horizon Book of the Middle Ages, so am not commenting on it at this time. I went through some more of my books in search of other examples. Specifically, from the "Medieval Health Handbook" printed by George Brazillier, Inc, 1976 there are several illustrations. In the color plate section, Turnips, XXIII, and Leeks XXVIII, both have pack baskets. These packs appear to have the arm strap methods, and not the chest strap. Additionally, in the black and white plate section, Turnips plate 23, 200, and 201 all seem to be similar to the color plate earlier in the book. In b&w plate 58, Yellow Colored Wine, the pack may not be a basket, but it clearly (to me) has two arm straps. In the book "Complete Paintings of Bruegel" from Classics of the World's Great Art, edited by P. Lecaldano, printed by Rissoli Editore 1967, in plate 4-5, "Battle Between Carnival and Lent" there is a person with a packbasket in the right panel, just below the center. Also, plate 25 "The Procession to Calvary" appears to have a very small packbasket in the foreground, bottom center-ish, which is similar in shape to the Bosch "Wayfarer" packbasket. One last citation: from the "Medieval Woman Calendar 1998, September" there is a man in a vineyard with a packbasket full of grapes. His arm(s) definitely go through the straps to carry the basket. Most of the examples I've cited tend to be in conjunction with agricultural activities, but they do prove the existence of both methods of straps. As carrying agricultural products can get quite heavy, it only makes sense that some type of arrangement be made for hauling such items. Now whether this translates into carrying one's personal belongings in a similar type of arrangement is a matter of opinion. I just wanted to point out their existence. Kathryn/Dore' Date: Fri, 28 Aug 1998 11:54:18 -0500 From: "I. Marc Carlson" Subject: re: Travel Gear Newsgroups: rec.org.sca > >Thank you for your response. I guess I had misunderstood the original >post looking for backpacks and had only responded to that portion of the >question. I wish to continue this conversation, and will point out the >various methods of straps used in the paintings and illustrations I cite. That's ok, I was probably being fussier than necessary since I had been the one that mentioned the Ice Man's back pack resembling certain modern styles. The original posting, as I recall, was just asking about back packs in general. >>>From "Hieronymus Bosch" Bosing >>>p62 "The Wayfarer" El Escorial, Monasterio de San Lorenzo >>>pp64-65 "The Wayfarer" Rotterdam, Museum Boymans-van Beuningen >>Could you give me an idea where in the picture this is? I can see the >>lady carrying hay on her back, the baby carried in the hood. I'm sure >>I'm just missing it. >I'm not sure we are talking about the same pictures... Ok, I see the problem. I couldn't find any picture of"The Wayfarer", but I did find a reference that said that "The Wayfarer" was also known as the "Hay Wain", so that's what I was looking at. Having stopped and just taken a look at as many of his paintings as I can, you are refering to the one listed in my sources as "The Land loper", and that seems to be the chest strapping that keeps intriguing me. (For those of you who can't see it, imagine a wicker clothes hamper, with lid, and a strap attached to the sides (a few inches down from the top) that reach across the hinge side. That strap is worn so that it passes over the upper arms, and the chest. I will take a look for the others as I can. >Now whether this translates into carrying one's personal belongings in a >similar type of arrangement is a matter of opinion. I just wanted to point >out their existence. Quite all right. I still don't think that they were commonly used for it though :) Marc/Diarmaid From: "Bill Schongar" Subject: Backpacks (piece of evidence?) Newsgroups: rec.org.sca Date: 27 Aug 1998 09:44:38 -0500 With the recent thread still skulking around my head, I happened to run across a picture of (what appears to be) a period carving of a traveller wearing a backpack. Unfortunately, the picture doesn't contain all the relevant info, so I don't know who carved it and exactly when. The picture itself is in "The Horizon Book of the Middle Ages" (1968, L.o.C. catalog number 68-27730) on page 161. The attribution for the carving is "Swaffam Church, Norfolk: National Buildings Record". Later today, when I have more time, I'm going to try and hunt down more details... -Bill Edited by Mark S. Harris p-backpacks-msg